
Best bagels in NYC
There's something about the water in NYC.
New Yorkers swear the water is what makes the bagel, and the city has been boiling and baking on that belief for over a century. Whether it is science or folklore, these are the bagels worth a line.
Liberty Bagels
Big, glossy bagels and adventurous flavors, from classic to Oreo cream cheese.
Ess-a-Bagel
Family-owned since 1976, with slightly sweet, plate-sized bagels.
2788 Bagels (the revived Absolute Bagels)
Smaller, denser, craggy bagels made fresh through the day.
Tompkins Square Bagels
Kettle-boiled, airy bagels that make a great egg-and-cheese.
Russ & Daughters
The classic appetizing shop: bagels with smoked fish and a real schmear.
Shelsky's of Brooklyn
An appetizing shop with caramelized, airy bagels.
Rollin' Bagels
A cart on Center Boulevard with chewy bagels sized for sandwiches.
Utopia Bagels
A shop since 1980 with a carousel oven and balanced, well-inflated bagels.
The water story is a popular local claim and is debated. Shops listed come from published best-of guides; check each shop for hours and lines.
More guides
Know a place we missed? Tell us.